I've just been to the barbers shop and when he tidied my neck up using his cutthroat razor he went bloody doolally. I was in serious need of some Germolene but alas had left it at home, so I decided to rub some Bonjela into the sore patches on my neck. It stung like a wretch and I even let out a yelp, but the sweet smell of the magical teething gel of hope brought me comfort and joy. This cancelled out the negative of the stingers and may have even lifted the whole experience into the positive. I wouldn't like to say.
To conclude, I would not recommend application of Bonjela for shave burn up. I would however suggest giving it a go as a shaving foam alternative. This is something I would be more than willing to try. I once tried using e45 as an alternative to shaving foam, for I had found myself in a bit of a rut shaving foam wise. It didn't work very well. The reason for this was that the razor kept getting stuck in my bristles. Fearing a cut or worse I avalanched my face with e45 and managed to pull off a rather half arsed shave, but a shave nevertheless. I think the Bonjela shave would be markedly better than the e45 shave, but that's just my opinion.